Why do Black people get dark circles?

Three reasons: genetic predisposition to periorbital hyperpigmentation (the most common cause on Fitzpatrick V to VI), thinner skin around the eye showing underlying vasculature, and accumulated PIH from rubbing or eczema in the eye area. Most darker-skinned people have a combination of these, which is why one-treatment approaches rarely work.

Do retinol eye creams work on dark circles for Black skin?

Sometimes, with caution. Retinol thickens thin under-eye skin and accelerates pigment turnover. But it can irritate, and the eye area on darker skin is especially reactive. Start with the lowest retinol concentration available (0.025 to 0.05 percent), use 2 to 3 nights per week, and buffer with eye cream first.

Will an eye cream actually fade my dark circles?

Depends on type. Pigmented circles respond well to vitamin C, niacinamide, and kojic acid eye creams. Vascular circles need vasoconstrictors (caffeine, peptides) and may need filler to mask the shadow. Structural circles (tear trough hollowing) only respond to dermal filler or surgery, not topicals. Shadow circles (skin tone variation) are best treated with concealer and brightening, not necessarily clinical change.

Dark Circles on Black Skin: 4 Types and What Each Needs

Most "dark circles" content treats them like one thing. On Black skin, they're four different conditions with four different treatments. Here's how to identify which kind you have — and what actually works on Fitzpatrick V–VI.

Walk into any beauty store and you'll find a wall of "dark circle" eye creams. They almost all assume the same cause: tired eyes, thin skin, maybe pigmentation. On melanin-rich skin, none of those assumptions are quite right. There are four genuinely different things that produce dark circles on Fitzpatrick V–VI, and each one needs its own approach.

Type 1 — Pigmented (the most common on darker skin)

Brown or grey discoloration in the under-eye area caused by excess melanin in the skin itself. Often genetic — runs in families. Worsened by sun exposure, eczema in the eye area, and rubbing. The pigment is IN the skin, not behind it.

How to identify: stretch the skin gently below the eye. Pigmented circles don't fade with stretching — the color is locked in the tissue. Edges blend gradually into surrounding skin.

Treatment: niacinamide 5% eye cream, vitamin C derivatives formulated for the eye area, kojic acid, daily SPF (even indoors — windows let through UV). Avoid harsh hydroquinone around the eye. Expect 4–6 months to see real change.

Type 2 — Vascular

The skin under the eye is thin (the thinnest skin on your body). Blood vessels beneath it can show through as bluish, purple, or even pink tinting. On darker skin, this often appears more brown-purple than blue.

How to identify: press gently below the eye and release. Vascular circles briefly fade and refill as blood returns. Color tends toward purple/blue undertone.

Treatment: caffeine eye creams constrict vessels temporarily. Peptide formulas (matrixyl, copper peptides) thicken the skin slightly over months. Sleep on your back with an extra pillow (gravity helps drain pooled blood). Cold compresses in the morning. For severe vascular circles, dermatologists can prescribe topical timolol off-label.

Type 3 — Structural (tear trough)

A hollow groove between the lower eyelid and cheek that casts a shadow. Not a pigment problem at all — it's the architecture of the face. Becomes more pronounced with age as fat pads under the eye redistribute.

How to identify: tilt your head back and look up at yourself in a mirror. If the dark area lightens dramatically, you're looking at a shadow, not pigment.

Treatment: topicals do not fix structural hollows. The honest options are: hyaluronic acid dermal filler (a dermatologist or qualified injector — finding one experienced with darker skin matters), fat grafting (more permanent, more invasive), or strategic concealer (lighter shade than your foundation, applied in an inverted triangle from inner corner downward).

Type 4 — Shadow / contrast

Sometimes the under-eye area isn't darker than the rest of your face — your eyelids and forehead are lighter. This is a contrast illusion, not a real darkening. Common on darker skin where pigment distribution varies across the face.

How to identify: compare under-eye color in good light to the apple of your cheek (not to lighter zones). If they match within a shade, your "dark circles" are actually contrast.

Treatment: brightening the surrounding skin (not the eye area) evens the contrast. Some people prefer concealer to even tone visually. There's no clinical "fix" needed — this is normal variation.

You probably have more than one type

Most people on Fitzpatrick V–VI have a combination. Pigmented + vascular is the most common pairing. Treatment plans should target both: a brightening eye cream (for pigmented) plus a vasoconstrictor (caffeine) for the vascular component. Layer them. Use morning and night.

Find out exactly which types of dark circles you have

Lumière scans the periorbital area and identifies pigmented, vascular, and structural components separately. Calibrated for Fitzpatrick V–VI. Free first scan.

Get my free skin scan ✦