Chemical exfoliation gets reduced to a simple choice in most skincare content: "use an acid." Reality is more nuanced. The acid family you pick — and the specific molecule within it — changes everything about your skin's response. This matters more on melanin-rich skin (Fitzpatrick V–VI), where the wrong acid family at the wrong concentration is the leading cause of post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation in adult skincare routines.

The 3 acid families at a glance

Family Best for Irritation
AHA (Glycolic, Lactic, Mandelic)Dullness, dark spots, fine lines, surface textureModerate
BHA (Salicylic)Acne, blackheads, oily skin, clogged poresModerate
PHA (Gluconolactone, Lactobionic)Sensitive skin, barrier repair, first-time acid usersVery low

AHAs — for surface concerns

Water-soluble. Work on the very top layer of skin. Dissolve the bonds holding dead cells together so they shed naturally.

BHAs — for pores and acne

Oil-soluble. The only acid family that can penetrate INTO pores and dissolve the sebum + dead-skin plugs that cause blackheads and acne.

PHAs — for sensitive skin

Newer category. Larger molecules than AHAs. Penetrate much more slowly = less irritation, less photosensitivity, gentler exfoliation. Also have humectant properties (they pull water into skin).

The melanin-rich skin pick For Fitzpatrick V–VI, start with PHA or mandelic acid. The larger molecule sizes mean slower penetration and less PIH risk. Glycolic acid at 10%+ on darker skin frequently produces post-exfoliation dark spots that take months to fade — defeating the purpose. PHA first, mandelic second, lactic third. Glycolic last if at all.

Concentration guide

The cardinal rules

  1. One acid family at a time when starting. Don't layer AHA + BHA + PHA in one routine.
  2. Daily SPF is non-negotiable on any acid. UV exposure on freshly exfoliated skin = more PIH.
  3. Pause acids before any waxing, dermal-needling, or laser treatment. Resume 1 week after.
  4. Don't combine acids with retinol on the same evening. Alternate nights.

Find out which acid family fits YOUR skin specifically

Lumière scans your skin and tells you whether PHA, mandelic, lactic, glycolic, or salicylic is the right starting point for your barrier state. Free first scan.

Get my free skin scan ✦

Related reading